1 This saying is trustworthy: "If someone aspires to the office of overseer, he desires a good work."
2 The overseer then must be above reproach, the husband of one wife, temperate, self-controlled, respectable, hospitable, an able teacher,
3 not a drunkard, not violent, but gentle, not contentious, free from the love of money.
4 He must manage his own household well and keep his children in control without losing his dignity.
5 But if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how will he care for the church of God?
6 He must not be a recent convert or he may become arrogant and fall into the punishment that the devil will exact.
7 And he must be well thought of by those outside the faith, so that he may not fall into disgrace and be caught by the devil's trap.
Vs. 1: This saying is trustworthy: "If someone aspires to the office of overseer, he desires a good work." "This saying is trustworthy" - Paul uses this phrase three times in this letter (see verses 1:15 and 4:9). It seems that he was the only apostle that reminded the readers what he was saying was true and could be trusted. I suspect part of this is he was not an original disciple/apostle and had to defend himself against accusations. This whole paragraph (or maybe one sentence, since it is written by Paul) deals with the local church organization. Paul is not dealing with gifts of the Spirit herein. Any organization will run smoother if the responsibilities for operation are defined. Paul describes two positions in the local church - overseer (also known as elder, or bishop) and deacon. "aspires" - Reaching out to take hold of this job. This person wants to do the job. "office of overseer" - When the church first started out, the only people in charge were the apostles. As the church began grow when new believers were added, it became clear the work load was too much for the apostles (see Acts 6:1-6). The message of hope was an immediate draw for people, especially widows, orphans, and the poor. The church began meeting their needs. So much time was being consumed taking care of the believers, the apostles did not have time to pray, study, preach and teach. Seven men were appointed to serve the needs of the church, so the apostles could do their job - teach, preach, and evangelize. The church spread rapidly out from Jerusalem into neighboring cities, and countries. Paul became the apostle who was called to spread the gospel to the Gentiles. It became quickly obvious there were not going to be enough apostles to preach, teach, and evangelize all of the churches scattered throughout the region. The Holy Spirit gave the spiritual gifts for this very reason - to continue the spread of the gospel to the whole world. Paul includes the gifts of administration in 1 Cor 12:8-10, 28 as part of the list of spiritual gifts for the benefit of the believers. The church of Jesus Christ is not just to meet spiritual needs. In America at this time, there is an effort (not by churches, mostly) to relegate our religion to just worship in the church on Sunday morning. According to detractors, our faith may be exercised there, and only there. Christians are not to live their faith 'in the world', but be cloistered inside the walls. However, it is clear from reading the book of Acts, and letters from Paul, Peter, and James, the church was to meet the needs, both physical and spiritual of the church community as well as go out into the non-churched world to spread the gospel of peace. The preachers and teachers (also gifts of the Spirit) were not to be taken away from their tasks of showing us the way God wants us to live out our faith. A collection of people without leaders will devolve into a mess without accomplishing the tasks. People need direction and leadership. This is not a knock on people, We operate better when we know what is expected of us, and when we know when it needs to be done, and in some cases how it is to be done. The consulting engineering firm where I worked designed the utility infrastructure for factories. We worked with architects to size the building correctly for its purpose. The mechanical engineers developed the water, and air supply, heating and ventilation systems. The electrical engineers developed the distribution for the power into the building and out to the various loads to run the plant. The engineers designed the piping or conduit and wire systems for these functions. The contractors took our designs and built the plant. It was exciting to walk into a plant as it came together and see the systems, whether power, or lighting, or controls, exist in three dimension that the engineer had visualized and put on paper. It is very possible for an owner to go to a contractor and have him build a facility without plans. But one of the benefits of a comprehensive design is the avoidance of interferences between disciplines - interferences are expensive to correct. "desires a good work" - It is a good thing for someone to want the job of elder or overseer. A church may ask a man to do the job. But, he need not accept if he doesn't feel qualified. It is not wrong for a man to want to do the job. This verse seems to say a man may want the job, and seek it out. No false humility is needed or required - acting too humble to offer yourself. The job of elder is never considered to be a 'ruler'. This is a job of service not for the power hungry. The requirements for the job listed later will allow the church to select only those who are suitable. Vs. 2: The overseer then must be above reproach, the husband of one wife, temperate, self-controlled, respectable, hospitable, an able teacher,
The list starts in next six verses (2-7) for the qualities and temperament needed to be an elder.
(1) “above reproach“ - This is a man people trust. He's not a criminal, he doesn't cheat others, doesn't cut corners. This reminds me of what was expected of Caesar's wife - she must have no appearance of impropriety. Psa. 32:2 "... how blessed is the man to whom the Lord does not impute iniquity, and in whose heart is no deceit."
(2) “husband of one wife” - Simple declarative: married; one man to one woman. I do not know if this would prevent a man who was divorced and is now re-married from being an elder. (A church I attended had this issue. The board of elders could not come to a unanimous decision - some felt the verse was literal "one wife"; he was re-married, therefore, two wives. Kinda makes you go, "Hmmmmmmm." )
“One wife” - I believe God had always intended that as the standard. God expected men and women to be faithful to each other, completely. God is not a polygamist. "You shall have no other gods before me." (Exo. 20:3, Deut. 5:7, Judg. 10:13). The prophets characterized the Jews turning to false gods as adultery - read the prophet Hosea. Jesus was also straightforward about the issue. If a man divorces his wife and marries another, he is committing adultery. (See Matt. 19:9, 10) - Husbands and wives are to be exclusive with each other (talking about sexual relationships) (See 1 Cor. 7:2,3) - There should be no divorce (See 1 Cor. 7:10,11) - Husbands and wives are bound to each other as long as one of them is alive. (See 1 Cor. 7:39). Since the elders and deacons were to be called from the church body of believers, then it is reasonable to guess that one man-one wife would need to be relatively common occurrence. Is it a command?
(3) “temperate“ - A sober man, not emotionally, but figuratively. This person does not over-indulge in alcohol (commentaries say moderate use of wine, but I suspect beer and distilled spirits fall into the same category.) Temperate can also mean to be in control of yourself, and capable of devoting your will and actions to accomplish a desired end, serving God and Jesus to further the kingdom. Although that is a valid goal, that word is not the one used here.
(4) “self-controlled” - A man of sound mind, capable of curbing one's desires and impulses.
(5) “respectable“ - A man who is modest in behavior. People will respect someone who is not wild and wooly, moderate and even-tempered in his behavior.
(6) “hospitable“ - A man who likes having guests in his home.
(7) “able teacher“ - A man who is capable of teaching others about the truths of the love of God.
Vs. 3: - not a drunkard, not violent, but gentle, not contentious, free from the love of money.
(8) "not a drunkard" - This is more emphatic than "temperate", a stronger sense, than 'moderate use of wine". Alcoholics need not apply for overseer, not stoners, nor drug addicts, either. Paul is not expecting an elder to be a teetotaler.
(9) "not violent, but gentle" - The elder is not to be pugnacious, a brawler, a fighter, someone who strikes out at people. Such a ‘violent’ person is a ruder, cruder version of the "self-controlled", or "temperate" man mentioned above. Likewise, this man is not eligible to be an overseer.
An interesting thought to ponder, can a man be an alcoholic or an abuser and no one know about it?
(10) "not contentious (peaceable) " - A man that is not to be argumentative. I think this word is part of the previous type, that is, the opposite of pugnacious, being someone who not only gentle but also not tending to argue and stir things up.
(11) "free from the love of money" - Not greedy. I like the way King James Version (KJV) "not greedy of filthy lucre". A word describes this 'avaricious' - 'an immoderate desire for wealth or gain.'
God wants a man who is even keeled, not veering wildly. James describes it as "like the surf of the sea, driven and tossed by the wind." We would call him a fine, upstanding citizen, without sarcasm intended. This is someone who may be trusted by both believers and non-believers alike.
Vs. 4: He must manage his own household well and keep his children in control without losing his dignity.
(12)"manage his own household" - Again, the aprobrium, 'fine, upstanding, citizen' fits here. Not only is his public persona real and respected, but his home - wife and family - is also fine and upstanding. The reputation of this man is known throughout the community.
(13) "keep his children under control" - Even his teenagers? (Joke.) A person hopes the training given his children will show they caught what you taught. Again, the public will see how your children act. Our children do not always believe that their behavior is a reflection upon the family and their parents. (By the way: our behavior as Christians is a reflection of our life in Christ, and upon Him. Are we under His control? Are we as obstreperous as rebellious teenagers? The world knows, they are watching.) Note that all this is to be done "without losing his dignity." Discipline without embarrassing yourself, or your kids.
Vs. 5: But if someone does not know how to manage his own household, how will he care for the church of God?
"
how will he care for the church of God?" - This is directly tied to the previous verse. Obviously the overseer is not a desk job, not a paper pusher. The office of overseer is one of service to the flock.
Vs. 6: - He must not be a recent convert or he may become arrogant and fall into the punishment that the devil will exact.
(14) "not be a recent convert" - This is an interesting comment, since when it was written most converts were 'recent'. I will amend that, some churches may have been around for about 20-30 years. But there wasn't the generational legacy you might have in your church. No family Bible with great-grandma's name, or grandma's name written in the fly leaf. Paul is saying that the overseer must be someone who has a personal history of belief and life in Christ. In other words, someone who has been discipled, and is a disciple. The elder must have the maturity to deal with the issues of the body. A new convert will probably not know the people making up the local church, their families, their illnesses, their problems, the interaction with each other.
(15) "arrogant" - A reason for not choosing a new convert to be an elder - pride! We can easily see how this problem would surface. If a man accepts Christ as Lord and Savior, and then quickly is named an elder of the church. He could begin to 'puff up', thinking too highly of himself. Does the new believer understand the power of prayer? Maybe, but perhaps not as well as a seasoned believer. Does he understand living in the power and control of the Holy Spirit? How could he? This is learned habit. Not having these attributes, and being a leader in the church, how cool is that? It is not hard to drift into arrogance in these conditions.
"fall into the punishment" - Interesting! Satan will exact a punishment, and obviously God will let it happen. What would that punishment be? (Note: other translations indicate "the same judgment as the devil." for this phrase.) How's that for a jaw-dropper? Satan lusted to be equal to God. (Isa. 14:12-15, Ezek. 28:14-19) He and his followers rebelled and were ejected from heaven. (Rev. 12:7-9, Luke 10:18). His ultimate location (can't really say 'end', because it is eternal punishment) is the lake of burning sulphur. (Rev. 20:10). His (Satan's) arrogance caused a might schism and war in heaven.
That being said, I find it difficult to believe that a Christian to drifts into arrogance because he was appointed an elder prematurely would be sent to hell. It is much more likely this part of the sentence is saying an elder who thinks more highly of himself than he ought to think (opposite of Rom. 12:3) too easily falls into the same sin as the Devil - pride leading to the sin of self-determination, that is, I don't need God.
Vs. 7: And he must be well thought of by those outside the faith, so that he may not fall into disgrace and be caught by the devil's trap.
(16) “be well thought of" - This is similar to 'beyond reproach" as seen above in verse 2. Psalm 15 has eleven (11) precepts of true religion (living out one's faith):
1 A Psalm of David. O LORD, who may abide in Your tent? Who may dwell on Your holy hill?
2 He who walks with integrity, and works righteousness, And speaks truth in his heart.
3 He does not slander with his tongue, Nor does evil to his neighbor, Nor takes up a reproach against his friend;
4 In whose eyes a reprobate is despised, But who honors those who fear the LORD; He swears to his own hurt and does not change;
5 He does not put out his money at interest, Nor does he take a bribe against the innocent. He who does these things will never be shaken.
"may not fall into disgrace" - The disgrace is to "fall into the devil's trap". It seems the Greek word is for 'snare' like for catching a bird; or "the allurements to sin by which the devil holds one bound". This reminds me of 'The Screwtape Letters' in which Satan's hench-demons (hench-angels doesn't work, or sound right) are encouraged to take a good thing and twist it to keep the believer from living an abundant life. The trap of arrogance is almost always embarrassment. The person is operating as if everything is under his control. The comeuppance will undermine the person in their position, or destroy the witness and effectiveness.
***